MuggleCast is one of several Harry Potter podcasts, and was featured as a Bad Podcast of the Week in Episode 029: Hit Points Are Gay. What caused it to be a BPOW was mostly just because it is about Harry Potter, which Patrick considers to be gay. One of the complaints was that there are too many Harry Potter podcasts. When Patrick began to introduce the bad podcast, Adam had guessed PotterCast. Both of these Harry Potter podcasts would frequently be in the top 10 at Podcast Alley, which upset Patrick as he could not understand why so many people would be excited about wizard that is a "12 year old boy who jacks off into girls' panties while waving a wand."

Another commentary regarded how sad it was that the newest Harry Potter book had quickly become the best selling book in America for the whole year when it had been out for a month. Patrick also pointed out the stupid naming convention of the books (____ of the ____). He also pointed out the lack of content they must have, mocking them with "Ehh, its a new week, ehh, no new books came out this week, Harry Potter is still a wizard, umm, we'll keep you updated if there's any changes to that..." Patrick also expressed his hopes that terrorists would attack the premiere of the upcoming movie.

Following MuggleCast being featured as the BPOW, Patrick recieved an email from Andrew from MuggleCast. This prompted him to begin saying "Send all your hate mail to andrew@staff.mugglenet.com" as well as other variations of that. This trend lasted for many episodes.

After some time, Patrick and Andrew had a conversation, and they had reached some sort of agreement that lead to Patrick to say to stop email bombing MuggleCast. MuggleCast was also in one of the segments of St. Patrick.